Apple Butter Ham and Cheese Tea Sandwiches

Apple Butter Ham and Cheese Tea Sandwiches

Ham and cheese is a classic combination that’s been around for a long, long time. So, naturally ham and cheese tea sandwiches are a common site at tea parties. As you know, here at Plum Deluxe we like to add our own spin to the classics, and this time around we are adding a single ingredient that really makes these little sandwiches something special: apple butter.

Two apple butter ham and cheese tea sandwiches are stacked together on a white plate.

Salty, Earthy, Sweet

The addition of apple butter to standard ham and cheese tea sandwiches changes the flavor, but also changes the whole texture of the sandwich. Apple butter adds a bit more moisture, something that really brings it all together. When it comes to the flavor difference, we are pretty sure your guests will find this awesome. Salty ham has always made a good partner for the mild, almost nutty flavor of Swiss cheese and the sweetness of apple butter. Bringing these three together creates the perfect blend of salty, earthy, and sweet. It’s a flavor combination that is sure to both comfort and surprise your guests in the best way.

We put this sandwich on rye bread because it is part of the quintessential image of a ham and cheese sandwich. Additionally, the flavor that a good rye bread can add really takes the sandwich to a whole other level. However, feel free to use any bread you prefer. It is always a nice touch to have different types of bread if you plan on serving different sandwiches. Not only does it make them easier to select, but it creates more visual appeal as well. Try adding a deviled egg salad on wheat and a brie and strawberry on white to the same tray as this ham and cheese tea sandwich and you will see what we are talking about.

Two apple butter ham and cheese tea sandwiches sit on a white plate with floral border.

Want to add even more depth and complexity to this simple sandwich? Try using our chai-infused apple butter recipe. The extra spice flavor is subtle enough not to overpower the other ingredients, but adds a certain depth of flavor that is truly out of this world. Because the chai flavor is subtle, it still pairs well with a strong chai such as our Rainy Day pu-erh. Even if you are using a traditional apple butter recipe, we still recommend pairing it with a nice chai, since the flavors go so well together. The Full Moon Chai with its sweet warming feel is a wonderful combination with this sandwich.

Fall Tea Party Menu

These apple butter ham and cheese tea sandwiches go well with nearly any menu, but they go especially well with a fall-themed menu. Try pairing it with a nice autumn soup, like caramelized carrot and sweet potato, or a squash quiche. A great dessert would be our Chai Monkey Bread or Apple Cardamom Cake.

Two apple butter ham and cheese tea sandwiches are stacked on a white plate with floral border.

Apple Butter Ham and Cheese Tea Sandwiches


  • 4 slices rye bread, crusts removed and halved
  • 1/4 lb thick-cut ham
  • 1/4 lb sliced Swiss cheese
  • 1/3 cup prepared apple butter
  • 1 tablespoon butter


Place 4 rye bread halves on plate or cutting board and layer equal amounts of ham and Swiss cheese on each piece. Smear a healthy dollop of apple butter onto the remaining pieces of bread and place on top, smeared side down.

Melt half of the butter in a large skillet over medium high heat, swirling to coat.

Place the sandwiches on the skillet and cook until toasted, about 1-2 minutes. Add the remaining butter and flip the sandwiches. Cook again until toasted and the cheese has melted.

Serve immediately.

Apple Butter Ham and Cheese Tea Sandwiches

Jessica Marcy

JC is from Upstate NY and is the blogger behind Sweet Love & Ginger. She believes in celebrating a healthy lifestyle and can be found enjoying the great outdoors, crafting, cooking and entertaining.

What Tea We're Sipping on Right Now

Gingerbread Chai Tea (Gingerbread Spice)

Tis the season for wonderful holiday rituals - including piping hot, comforting mugs of chai! $7/oz.

Add to cart
raspberry cocoa tea

Raspberry Cocoa Truffle Tea

Slow down and sip a cup of decadence with this limited-edition Valentine's Tea – you deserve it. $7/oz.

Add to cart

Chocolate Rosemary Caramel Herbal Tea

Savory and sweet - the perfect balance. $7/oz

Add to cart

Loose Tea Accessories + Teaware

Care Packages (Tea Gift Sets)


Sweets & Treats

Popular Tea Themes Right Now:
Fruit Flavored Tea, Any Dessert Flavored Tea, Our Best Floral Teas