Success Item added to your cart

Blender's Choice

Blender's Choice

Always Ethically Sourced

Free Sample with Every Order

100% Secure Checkout

Backed by Sip Satisfaction Guarantee

Blender's Choice

Blender's Choice

Love trying new teas? Then meet the Blender's Choice. This is not some stale leftover sitting around the studio. We will choose a blend for you based on your order history, current and past.


It might be a signature blend. It might be a limited-edition. You might even get lucky and land one of the tea club teas. Because we buy ingredients and blend by the pound, we often have a little extra of teas that were not part of an order or subscription. It is a surprise, so it is only $6 to nudge you to take the plunge and try something new.

$6.00/oz
$8.00 $6.00/oz
Sale Sold out

Love trying new teas? Then meet the Blender's Choice. This is not some stale leftover sitting around the studio. We will choose a blend for you based on your order history, current and past.


It might be a signature blend. It might be a limited-edition. You might even get lucky and land one of the tea club teas. Because we buy ingredients and blend by the pound, we often have a little extra of teas that were not part of an order or subscription. It is a surprise, so it is only $6 to nudge you to take the plunge and try something new.

View full details

Always Ethically Sourced

Free Sample with Every Order

100% Secure Checkout

Backed by Sip Satisfaction Guarantee

Questions? Check our free tea guides or customer service FAQ

Thoughtfully Sourced Ingredients

Ethical Sourcing

From field to cup, we're deeply committed to both sustainability and exceptional quality. That's why we build direct relationships with farmers we know and trust – from all over the world to right here in the Pacific Northwest – to carefully select only the finest natural, organic, and wildcrafted ingredients.

All of our ingredients are fairly traded, supporting ethical work conditions and fair wages for the communities that cultivate them.

Clean Ingredients

Ingredients are always listed. We don't use stevia or sweeteners in teas. Our teas are also vegan, dairy free, and gluten free. (This does not apply, of course, to our sweets and treats section.)

Extracts and Essences

To deliver peak freshness and consistent quality, we blend and flavor our teas in-house. We use pure extracts and essences derived from real ingredients like fruits, flowers, nuts, or spices – similar to baking extracts or essential oils, but formulated specifically for the delicate art of tea blending.

Our essences and flavors are made only with real, natural ingredients – nothing artificial. You may also find essences like "butterscotch" or "caramel" in our tea ingredients. Rest assured, these aren't artificial flavorings! We use a special proprietary blend of real, natural ingredients, gently distilled and balanced to embody those rich and comforting flavor notes.

Commitment to Quality

We go the extra mile to ensure exceptional quality. Before any tea earns the Plum Deluxe stamp of approval, it undergoes thorough testing for aroma, visual appeal, taste, and even its ability to offer a satisfying second steep. When you choose our teas, you can be confident you're selecting only the very best, crafted with care just for you.

Still curious? We're always happy to chat! Reach out to us at hello@plumdeluxe.com with any questions you have about our ingredients or sourcing practices.

Package Sizing & Preparation

Teas are packaged by the ounce. Some of our best sellers are available in 4 oz sizes, and tea club members can buy by the pound and save 40%.

By default, we provide hot tea instructions, but all teas can be made hot or cold.
- Hot Tea: Add 1 flat tsp of tea to 8 oz hot water & steep per instructions. Approx 16 cups per package.
- Cold Tea: Add 1.5 flat tsp of tea to 8 oz cold water. Steep in fridge 8 hours. Approx 2 medium-sized pitchers iced tea per package.

Shipping information

Shipping is $6.99 per order to all United States and APO/FPO addresses. International shipping is $14.99 per order.

We strive to keep our prices fair and affordable, which is why our shipping costs only cover postage and handling, no hidden extra fees.

Don’t forget: 

  • Free Shipping Over $55: Stock up on your favorites (or try something new!) and shipping is on us.  
  • Tea Club Members Get Free Shipping, Always: Join our community of tea lovers for as little as $10 a month and enjoy free shipping on every single order. Plus: exclusive blends, early access to new flavors, and unique discount offers.
Ask a question

Plum Deluxe teas are hand-blended and shipped directly from our small business based in Portland, Oregon. Our teas are never pre-sweetened and and made with only the freshest, highest quality ingredients. Whether you’re new to tea or a seasoned tea aficionado, we have a flavor you’ll love.

Have a question you’ve not found an answer for yet? Check out our FAQ here.

Sip Satisfaction Guarantee

We care deeply that you find your perfect cup of tea! If you're not 100% satisfied with your purchase, simply let us know and we'll be happy to issue a full refund or send you a replacement, no questions asked. Your happiness is our top priority, and we're committed to making every sip a joyful experience!

  • 5 stars: 105 (91%)
  • 4 stars: 8 (7%)
  • 3 stars: 3 (3%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 0 (0%)
K
Karen J.
It's like they know me

I always look forward to seeing what my Blender's Choice will be; I haven't been disappointed yet. Some of them I've enjoyed hot and some are better chilled, but all have been delicious.
The only con is falling in love with one knowing that I probably won't be able to get more (looking at YOU, Heart's Delight!). So far I've also received Golden Chai Black, Apple Cinnamon Warmth Black, Mango Dragonfruit Refresher, and Happy Hour Herbal, and I'm eagerly awaiting my next batch of surprises.

L
Lynn B.
At what temperature did you drink this tea?: Hot
Did you add anything to this tea?: Sweetener
Plum Deluxe Teas are the BEST!

I have been a member of the Plum Deluxe tea club for many years and have never once been disappointed. Teas don't come better, nor does the service you get with any questions. Love my Plum Deluxe!

S
Sydney
At what temperature did you drink this tea?: Hot
Did you add anything to this tea?: Milk/creamer, Sweetener
Delicious tea

I was sent a black tea blend that I wouldn't have thought to choose myself. It's delicious and a new favorite.

C
Carrie S.
At what temperature did you drink this tea?: Hot
Did you add anything to this tea?: Milk/creamer
A New Favorite!

I took a chance on a Blender’s Choice tea and ended up LOVING it!

J
JoAnn P.G.
At what temperature did you drink this tea?: Hot
Did you add anything to this tea?: Sweetener
Sooo tasty!

Custom ordered Sweet Crème - originally a Halloween sample flavor last year. I can’t begin to tell you how delicious it is or how happy I was to be able to order a full pound! My blenders choice was Limoncello, which I absolutely loved as well.

Hi JoAnn! We're so happy to hear you enjoyed the Sweet Crème and Limoncello blends. Thank you for sharing your favorites and for your support. Enjoy your teas!

D
Deborah W.
At what temperature did you drink this tea?: Hot, Iced
Did you add anything to this tea?: Sweetener
Very smooth and has the best vanilla flavor

I love this flavor but love it more when combined with porch sippin pecan it’s good hot or cold

D
Danielle M.
At what temperature did you drink this tea?: Hot
Did you add anything to this tea?: Sweetener
I was happy

I was sent a really great tea to try that I love. I'll definitely order blender's choice again in the future.

M
Melissa M.
So many great discoveries!!

I LOVE choosing Blenders Choice. I have tried so many amazing flavors this way and I've never had a bad tea! Often the bags are a little more full than a normal bag and it's just a little extra delight.

t
traveltcg
At what temperature did you drink this tea?: Hot
Did you add anything to this tea?: I did not add anything
Wonderful blend!

We loved the apple tea we received! We often reached for that one before the teas we ordered!

V
Virginia B.
Did you add anything to this tea?: I did not add anything
Really smooth

It's perfect any time of day.

L
Linda W.
At what temperature did you drink this tea?: Hot
Did you add anything to this tea?: I did not add anything
Earl grey tea is smooth!

This is my second time getting the mindful morning tea. It is so nice to drink. I hope to keep it on hand all the time. It's smooth taaste is good for a break in my day.

C
Cindy B.
At what temperature did you drink this tea?: Iced
Did you add anything to this tea?: I did not add anything
The one sent to me should be a regular

Oh, MY!!!! This one was one of your best...very yummy and one I will take my time using as this deliciousness is one to savor every time it's used.
If it ever comes out as one of the regular teas I will order.

I
Icarus B.
At what temperature did you drink this tea?: Hot
Did you add anything to this tea?: I did not add anything
New tea

I was happily surprised by this tea. Green tea with jasmine and cornflower. It was quite nice.
I tend to prefer chai (which has gotten much harder to find). I was surprised to not need sugar/honey

A
Andrew D.
At what temperature did you drink this tea?: Hot
Did you add anything to this tea?: Sweetener
Good

Good Tea

K
Kathleen W.
At what temperature did you drink this tea?: Hot
Did you add anything to this tea?: Sweetener
Icy Peach

It was icy peach tea. I had another one on hand. Very good peach tea! Highly recommend!

K
Katie B.
At what temperature did you drink this tea?: Hot
Did you add anything to this tea?: Sweetener
Best Surprise Ever!

I have never done the Blenders Choice before and gave it a whirl and loved what I received!!
Snow Day Herbal is so good and I’m not sure that I would have ordered it (I stick to my favs) but will be ordering this again!!
And will be ordering Blenders Choice again too!
Well done Plum Deluxe! Your teas bring me so much joy!

P
Patti E.
At what temperature did you drink this tea?: Hot
Did you add anything to this tea?: Sweetener

Love the flavor of this tea not overpowering

S
Sarah J.
A surprise that's nice!

Whether it's something you've tried, something new or something you don't like it's all in good fun. $6 for surprise tea is a fabulous deal! Even if you don't enjoy your surprise you can gift or trade it away.

L
Laura B.
At what temperature did you drink this tea?: Hot
Did you add anything to this tea?: Milk/creamer, Sweetener
Blender’s Choice- read my mind!

I don’t often opt for a mystery tea, but what I received was actually on my list for my next order!

Porch Sippin’ Pecan- my fave for Autumn Tea Lattes!

A
Angie B.
At what temperature did you drink this tea?: Hot
Did you add anything to this tea?: Sweetener
Great choice!

The Blender's Choice that was picked for me is Rhubarb Coffee Cake Oolong, and it couldn't have been more perfect. I love all these flavors. The tartness of the rhubarb essence and apple pieces with the subtle cinnamon and vanilla is just delicious. I drank it hot and added a tiny bit of honey. It's good without sweetener, but when I added the honey, it brought out more of the flavors. Really loved this one!

C
Caitlin B.
At what temperature did you drink this tea?: Hot, Iced
Did you add anything to this tea?: Milk/creamer, Sweetener
EXCELLENT choice, more like

Relatively new to tea but not new enough that I don't have preferences. Being relatively green to tea (no pun intended), I figured this Blenders Choice bag would be great for trying out something new and I was ABSOLUTELY right. Became a new favorite for sure!

Received: Picard Black
As someone who loves tea with milk, Picard Black was just incredible. I'm very partial to blacks given how well they pair with cream, and the kind of profiles they bring but man this one takes the cake so far. Easily a new favorite. Wonderful notes of pecan, orange, maybe a bit of cinnamon even, and don't even get me started on how floral it smells! 😍 Excellent flavor, excellent pairing, and excellent choice.

I'm extremely pleased if you couldn't tell and I look forward to my next lucky draw! ❤️🍀

H
H.W.
At what temperature did you drink this tea?: Hot
Did you add anything to this tea?: Sweetener
A fun and tasty surprise

I love trying new things and Plume Deluxe is always so good and picking out tasty surprises. Will continue to add one of these to my future orders!

B
Brian R.
At what temperature did you drink this tea?: Hot
Did you add anything to this tea?: I did not add anything
You can't go wrong with this

I have ordered this frequently, and I have not received anything that wasn't worth the money and the time to brew it, it's a fantastic way to open your tastes and get an idea what they have available to you.

L
Larysa H.
Unique tea

Thank you!

L
Leslie B.

I decided to try a Blenders Choice with my second Plum Deluxe order, I received Pecan Creme Black- perhaps one of my favorite teas so far! I have decided to add a Blenders Choice to every order I place ( my third order is due to arrive in a few days).

F
Florence T.

I order Blender’s Choice about 50% of the time just to mix up my tea palette and try new teas that I probably wouldn’t select on my own. At $5 per pouch, it’s a great way to be adventurous and I have discovered some truly delicious teas that have become ongoing purchases for me. I highly recommend giving Blender’s Choice a try!

D
Deanna K.

This is a great option. I ordered this twice. Both times I received a tea I would not have necessarily ordered for myself. And both times I have loved that tea. It is a fun way to give yourself a gift and try something new.

why choose us

What Makes Us Different

Crafted to resonate with your mood and the moments you cherish.

Luxury that doesn't sacrifice your health.

Hand-blended in small batches for perfectly balanced flavor.

Natural, organic, & wildcrafted ingredients from family farms we know and trust.